In 1990, famous chefs from around the world gathered in Monte Carlo to celebrate the 70th birthday of noted food writer, Craig Claiborne. Instead of gifts of monetary or material value, Claiborne requested that each chef give him a hand written recipe. One can only wonder what a collection of treasured recipes he collected that evening.
Hand written recipes remain, to me, a great gift. Yes, the quantities are often vague (ie. a “handful” of this and a “pinch” of that). There may be detailed instructions. Or not (ie. “bake it until it’s done.”) Certainly the art of sharing recipes written on 3×5″ index cards is not commonplace these days. Which makes them even more special. And when a recipe has been handed down from generation to generation, you know it’s a keeper.
These meatballs and sauce are no exception.
Years ago, one of my husband’s co-workers was raving about her husband’s grandmother’s Italian meatballs and sauce. She was kind enough to write down the ingredients and some basic instructions which we followed to the letter. The results were nothing short of exceptional, and hopefully this recipe will be passed on down for generations to come.
THE MEATBALLS
There are two teams when it comes to meatball making: #TeamBrown and #TeamSimmer. This recipe falls in the latter category. I have to say I’m with nonna on this one as well. Simmered meatballs are incredibly tender, pick up the flavor of the sauce, and retain their shape. This recipe calls for a combination of ground beef, pork and veal along with seasoned breadcrumbs, Parmesan cheese and eggs. Rolled into balls then simmered slowly in the sauce until they’re melt-in-your-mouth tender. They also freeze well, so we always triple the recipe, then freeze them so they’re ready to go anytime.
MARINARA SAUCE THREE WAYS
Why three ways? Because it’s nice to have options!
Sauce #1 “The Real Deal” This is the original nonna’s sauce that accompanied the meatball recipe. And much like the meatball recipe, this one is a classic. So easy to make with ingredients you probably have on hand. Incredibly versatile and like the meatballs, you can make a big batch and easily store in the freezer.
Sauce #2 “Gardener’s Delight” is a bit more labor intensive. OK….a LOT more labor intensive actually. But, if you happen to be a gardener and grow tomatoes, I will be linking to an incredible sauce from one of our favorite cooking and gardening bloggers: Kaleb from Wyse Guide. Interestingly he states the recipe comes from a church cookbook his mom had when he was growing up.
It is a good day’s work, between processing your tomatoes, then prepping the ingredients, simmering the sauce then finally canning. But good heavens there’s nothing like cracking open a jar of that sauce in the middle of winter and tasting all the bright flavors of the summer garden.
SAUCE #3 “Store Bought is Fine” Finally, completely opposite from Kaleb’s recipe is Option three, which is purchasing a jar of already made sauce. There are so many options available but many food fans agree (myself included) on one brand that rules the sauce world. I will link to that as well. Hint: it’s Ina Garten’s favorite “store bought” sauce as well 🙂
Until next time, eat well, be well and love lots ❤
AMAZING ITALIAN MEATBALLS and MARINARA SAUCE THREE WAYS
Meatballs:
- 1 to 1-1/2 pounds of ground meat (any combination of beef, pork and or veal) (See Note 1>)
- Salt and pepper to taste
- Approximately 3/4 cup Italian seasoned dry breadcrumps
- 1/2 cup grated Parmesan cheese or a combination of Parmesan and Romano
- 1 egg, beaten
- Milk as needed (per instructions)
Directions:
Lightly break up meat into a large mixing bowl. Add salt and pepper to taste, then breadcrumbs, cheese and egg. Pour in one cup of milk, then gently hand mix the ingredients. Do not overwork! Add additional milk if mixture is too dry.
Shape into balls about the size of golf balls. (See Note 2>).
Place meat balls into simmering marinara sauce, cook until done, about 30 minutes on low simmer (about 45 minutes if cooking from frozen).
Serve immediately over spaghetti. Serves 3-4 (approx. 9 to 10 meatballs in total)
Note 1> I’m going to get very specific here, because this is IMPORTANT. Your meatballs will only be as good as the quality of the meat that goes into them. For ground beef, I only buy either freshly ground beef from my butcher or grass fed beef. Superior flavor and texture. Too many chain grocery stores sell cheap, stringy ground beef which will make your meatballs tasteless and tough.
For this recipe, I use equal parts lean ground beef (90% lean), ground pork and ground veal. You can omit either the pork or veal, or both, if you’d like.
Note 2> We’ve found the ideal size to be just slightly larger than a golf ball. With that size, for 1# of meat, you should get about 9-10 meatballs. A kitchen scale does come in handy for measuring out equal portions.
Marinara Sauce #1″The Real Deal”
- 1 large can (28 oz.) crushed tomatoes (favorite brands are Cento or Muir Glen organics)
- 1 can (6 oz) tomato paste
- 1 can (15 oz.) tomato sauce or passata – OPTIONAL (See Note 1>)
- 2 cloves garlic, minced or pressed
- 1 small onion, chopped (see Note 2>)
- 1 tsp basil
- 1 tsp salt
- 1 tsp black pepper
- 1 celery stalk, cut into 4-inch pieces
Directions:
Place tomatoes and tomato paste in a pan, plus one can (from tomato paste can) of water. Add additional canned sauce, if using.
Add remaining ingredients, simmer on low heat, stirring occasionally, until slightly reduced, flavors are concentrated and onions are cooked through, about 30 minutes. Remove celery and discard.
Makes enough for 1 lb. spaghetti.
Note 1> If you feel the amount of sauce is adequate using just the crushed tomatoes, paste and water, then no need to add additional sauce.
Note 2>You also have the option of sautéing your chopped onion and garlic first until slightly softened. Then add the tomato products and proceed with the recipe as written.
Marinara Sauce #2 “Gardeners Delight”
Kaleb Wyse is the Midwestern gardener/cook, and creator of our all-time favorite garden marinara sauce. If your tomato garden runneth over, and you have the patience and time for canning, this is the sauce for you! Fresh, processed tomatoes are slowly simmered with onions, fennel, garlic and plenty of fresh herbs. The sauce is incredibly rich and complex. Opening a jar in the middle of winter is one of life’s greatest pleasures.
Kaleb’s Spaghetti Sauce and Canning Instructions
If you’re going to tackle this one, I highly recommend viewing the video first for some handy tips. And, even if you’re not ready to tackle this sauce, check out Kaleb’s blog Wyse Guide – many great recipes, gardening and decorating/lifestyle ideas. The best of the Midwest!
Marinara Sauce #3 “Store Bought Is Fine”
Bottom line: if this is Ina Garten’s go to store bought sauce, that’s all the endorsement I need! Popular food blog The Kitchn also recently named Rao’s #1. Rao’s was always my brand of choice as well (before we started canning our own). Wonderfully balanced flavors. All natural and very important to me: no added sugar! So. for the perfect quick weeknight dinner, simmer some of the delicious Italian Meatballs with a jar of Rao’s. Serve over spaghetti and pass the Parm!